Choosing the right tires for your car is imperative. When it comes to life and death situations, tires can make all the difference. A tire’s traction and grip on various surfaces /must be considered. Additionally, you should consider how durable they are. It can be tricky to choose all-season tires, but your best bet is to choose between Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender.
BF Goodrich Advantage T/A is a grand touring tire that can handle all types of weather, even light snow. Despite having excellent traction in all seasons, this tire offers sporty looks and is suitable for everyday use. A sedan or sporty coupe can use it.
Michelin Defender, its competitor, is also an excellent all-weather tire. The tire is suitable for small crossover vehicles, minivans, and family cars. With this tire, you can ride in comfort even at lower speeds.
There is no question that both tires perform well on most cars, but which is the best? So let’s have a look at the comparison between Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender.
BF Goodrich Advantage Control Overview
All-season tires like these are affordable, durable, and multipurpose. These tires usually have hard compounds that affect performance, ride comfort, and noise reduction. Due to the brand’s research and development, BF Goodrich Advantage Control tires are surprisingly good compared with other tires in this price range.
BF Goodrich claimed these tires would provide “dependable all-season traction”. In addition, these tires promised short braking distances, comfort, quietness, and low noise without compromising the long tread life of the tires.
To accomplish all this, BG Goodrich added silica to the compound used to make the tread. A winter tire with this material provides excellent traction on wet and slick surfaces. As a result, the tread designed to retain its flexibility at both hot and cold temperatures, ensuring excellent traction every time.
These tires have symmetric tread patterns that provide a quiet and comfortable ride, according to the manufacturer. As a result of BFGoodrich’s computer-optimized tread design, BFGoodrich claims a longer tire life with even tread wear.
A high-quality tire with Aqua Flume Technology and G-Wedge stabilizers, able to keep the vehicle steady even when driving fast or braking hard, as well as performing well in wet conditions due to its water displacement design.
BF Goodrich tires reinforced with nylon reinforcements, two-ply polyester casings, and solid steel belts. Learn more at here.
BFGoodrich’s Tire Families
Tire families grouped based on their use cases by BFGoodrich.
1. Advantage
Touring tires are a common sight in the tire industry, and BFGoodrich’s answer is the Advantage family of tires. Providing excellent comfort levels and longer-lasting performance, these tires cover all the bases for what a driver needs all year long.
The options limited, but BFGoodrich designed them to fit a variety of vehicles. You can choose from models like the Control, T/A, and T/A Sport, which offer various features. Some are more refined, while others are a bit more agile. As an all-weather SUV, light truck, and CUV, the T/A Sport comes in an LT variant.
2. g-Force
If G-Force tires offer performance you can count on. With these tires, you will lose out on refinement, but you will get tires that will perform more sportily.
In These tires can only fitted to passenger cars, so CUVs and SUVs are out of luck. There is a summer and an all-season version of the COMP-2. The second one is suitable for use in snow as well as in dry conditions. In dry conditions, the Rival S tire offers even better performance, designed primarily for the track. A Winter model, as you might have guessed, is a winter tire with some performance features.
3. Radial
On On the slightly more affordable end of the performance segment, BFGoodrich has another family of tires you might consider. For those seeking sportier tires, the Radial models are a good choice. This is essentially a middle ground between the g-Force tire and the Advantage tire.
It is also an all-season tire that can only fitted to passenger cars. As for models, there aren’t a lot to choose from. T/A and T/A Spec are two tires, with minor improvements on the second.
4. All-Terrain
After moving away from passenger cars, we come to off-road tires. As you can probably guess from the name, BFGoodrich’s All-Terrain models intended to provide decent performance both on and off the road.
T/A KO2 is the only model in the All-Terrain family, so fitment shouldn’t be an issue. Trail-Terrain T/A also belongs to this family, but doesn’t carry the All-Terrain name. In this tire, you can expect a toned-down performance from the T/A KO2, and the tire is more road-ready.
5. Mud-Terrain
Another tire family that needs no explanation. In terms of off-road performance, BFGoodrich Mud-Terrain tires are the best option. There aren’t a lot of models in this family, but they come in a variety of sizes.
Mud-Terrain is available in two flavors, KM2 and KM3, with KM3 replacing KM2. Despite this, your tires deliver outstanding performance under harsh conditions. In addition, the T/A KM3 is available in a UTV variant.
6. Winter
BFGoodrich also offers dedicated winter tires in addition to the other families on this list. These studless tires offer superior winter performance over all-season or all-weather tires.
The T/A KSI is the only model available. The tire is available in a wide range of options, and it is suitable for all passenger cars. Some CUVs or SUVs may even be able to fit it, considering the options.
7. Commercial
Beware of the name that fools you. A highway tire is for SUVs and light trucks in the Commercial group, as they cover the touring segment of the larger vehicles. The same applies to commercial vehicles if the size is correct.
The T/A All-Season 2 is the only model currently available. With a well-refined and long-lasting all-season tire, you can use it in snowy conditions.
Michelin Defender Overview
There was an asymmetric tread pattern on the previous version of Defender2 tires (T+H). Michelin returned to the classic symmetrical design used on most all-season, multipurpose tires. This model features deeper grooves on the tread surface to improve grip on a variety of surfaces. Moreover, the new tread design eliminates water more efficiently, providing better traction in wet weather.
Additionally, the compound has updated with a good amount of silica to provide great traction in all conditions.
With this model, Michelin improved the performance and comfort without sacrificing strength. There are more biting edges on the tire’s sipe blocks, increasing traction and stability. Michelin’s SipeLock technology has used to design the sipe blocks. Thus, they linked, creating a network that reduces noise and vibration caused by tire friction with the road. Using Michelin’s patented PIANO technology (Pressure Influence on Acoustic Noise Optimization), this model designed to reduce noise from pressure changes.
The Michelin tire familyreinforced double steel belt as their BF Goodrich counterparts, covered by polyamide, making them safe and durable even when driving at high speed.
Michelin’s Tire Families
On the grouping side of things, Michelin has a pretty standard set of features for each tire family.
1. Pilot
These are the tires you’d buy if you’re willing to sacrifice a little refinement for the best possible performance. There are some decently comfortable options among these models, so not every one is harsh.
Sport All-Season 4, Sport 4s, and Alpin 5 are Michelin passenger car tires that cover all three weather conditions. SUV badges can also found on the same models, covering that market segment as well. There is also the Diamaris model in this group of cars. Michelin offers the Pilot MXM4, which provides excellent grip and traction without being harsh.
2. Primacy
Our next offering is Michelin’s best touring family of tires – Primacy. A well-refined tire with the latest and best technologies, these tires can offer decent performance.
This family of tires includes models like the Tour A/S, LTX, and XS, which designed to fit everything from small economy cars to larger SUVs. In addition to these models, there are others that are summer models, such as the MXM4 and MXV4. HP and Primacy 3 are the only two sizes available for passenger cars under those conditions.
3. Premier
In many ways, the Premier family of tires is similar to the Primacy family. You should be able to find a tire that fits your vehicle thanks to the wide range of sizes available.
Both the A/S and LTX are all-season models. One is for passenger cars, and the other is for CUVs and SUVs. These tour tires aim to offer a well-refined feel and a relatively long lifespan.
4. Latitude
One of Michelin’s families, the Latitude, designed specifically for specific vehicles. Its best feature is that it covers multiple weather conditions, each with its own features and driving characteristics.
Michelin offered three major Latitude models: Tour, Alpin, and Sport, designed as all-seasons, winter tires, and summer tires, respectively. For people with SUVs and CUVs, the Latitude offers several additional models.
5. X-Ice
It’s not impossible to drive in the winter, but you need proper tires to do so. In addition to the winter options within the other Michelin families, there is one specifically designed for these conditions. In addition to passenger cars, the X-Ice family also offers SUVs.
There are non-studdable models in the X-Ice lineup, including the Snow, Xi2, and Xi3. Snow SUV is also available for SUV owners, covering that segment as well. The North can provide extra performance on ice in some cases. In addition to passenger cars, Michelin also offers studdable tires for CUVs and SUVs.
6. Defender
In terms of its family of cars, Michelin known for making some overlaps, and the Defender is a good example of this. The manufacturer of these tires aims for longevity and refinement. This isn’t too different from some of the others on this list, but the technologies and some features aren’t the same.
Defender’s lineup consists of only two models: T+H and LTX M/S. First, you can choose from passenger cars to SUVs, while second, you can choose bigger vehicles, including light trucks. Within these two models, there are some overlaps, especially in terms of sizes for CUVs.
7. Energy
Several premium brands offer some models at a slightly more affordable price, and Michelin is no exception. Despite not being able to compete with the big players, these touring tires designed to compete with other midrange brands.
Energy tires come in two variants, the LX4 and Saver. The LX4 is available both as a summer tire and an all-season tire. Michelin aimed to offer a wide range of applications, including smaller models for older cars.
8. CrossClimate
The CrossClimate is one of Michelin’s many new models or improvements. In the all-season grand touring segment, Michelin’s latest addition has proven very strong so far.
It’s hard to find the original CrossClimate model nowadays, which isn’t surprising. You’re looking at some of the best grand touring tires with the CrossClimate+ and CrossClimate 2. A wide range of applications is also possible with these models due to their wide range of sizes.
9. LTX
Last but not least is the LTX family. The previous families of Michelin have some LTX models. However, the manufacturer went with entirely new models. Depending on your needs, there are two models to choose from, ranging from CUVs to light trucks.
In both on- and off-road conditions, Michelin offers the A/T2, an all-terrain tire capable of decent off-road performance without a lot of drawbacks. M/S2 tires are essentially touring tires if you don’t take your SUV or light truck off-road. Regardless of the model you choose, the tires you’ll get will be all-season.
Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender: Tire Line
1. BF Goodrich Advantage Control Tire Line
The BFGoodrich Advantage Control Tire provides a quiet ride for drivers. BF This model introduced by Goodrich in 2021 to offer consumers better materials and technology than its competitors.
To improve tire grip on wet paved roads and other difficult driving conditions, silica and other compounds added. These tires also feature BF Goodrich’s patented Aqua-Flume Technology, which enhances wet performance even further.
On the thread pattern, this technology consists of contoured grooves. By evacuating water from the tire’s contact patch, these grooves help reduce hydroplaning and improve traction and stability in wet weather.
Additionally, the tires have sidewall stabilizers to improve ride quality and control. Moreover, the American tire manufacturer, now part of Michelin’s conglomerate, developed these tires to be silent and long-lasting.
2. Michelin Defender Tire Line
There is a new version of the Michelin Defender which replaces the Michelin Defender T+H that is being discontinued. It isn’t common for Michelin to discontinue tires overnight; they keep making old models for a while to allow users to get replacements without hassle.
Therefore, the old Defender T+H will take a while to disappear from the market. As long-lasting tires with Michelin’s quality seal, the T+H, Defender designed to provide efficient traction in all weather conditions, including some snow. In addition to their circumferential grooves, they have great wet handling, similar to their BF Goodrich counterparts.
Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender: Performance Comparison
BF Goodrich Advantage Control Performance
1. Dry Performance
The hardness of all-season tires makes them lose grip compared with summer or high-performance tires. Due to its tread design and numerous notches, the BF Goodrich Advantage Control provides excellent traction.
With their stiff sidewalls fitted with g-wedge stabilizers and good braking performance on hot, dry pavement, these tires provide good performance on dry roads. Their tread design makes them safe to drive at high speeds, keeping the vehicle in contact with the road at all times.
2. Wet Performance
With their silica-rich compound and Aqua-Flume Technology, these tires perform well on wet surfaces. Compared to tires of the same and higher tiers, these tires have one of the shortest wet braking distances and no aquaplaning issues. Water evacuated very efficiently, ensuring that the tread is in constant contact with the road. As long as you drive safely and don’t drive too fast, these tires have an excellent performance under heavy rain.
3. Snow Performance
In light snow, these tires offer decent traction, like most models in their category. Almost as well as these tires perform on wet roads, mild snowy roads have similar friction coefficients.
If you have to drive on frozen roads or in areas with deep snow and extreme temperatures, you should use snow chains or winter tires. The tires on this model weren’t created for use in such conditions, and riding your vehicle with them is dangerous.
4. Comfort and Noise
They provide good ride quality considering they are all-season tires. These tires absorb most road imperfections and slight bumps, even when they don’t have the outstanding ride quality of grand touring tires. Also, these tires scored a 10/10 on NVH (Noise Vibration Hardness) tests, meaning they are extremely quiet, which makes riding even more pleasant. They provide a comfortable and pleasant ride without breaking the bank.
Pros And Cons of BF Goodrich Advantage Control
Pros
- Wet traction, handling, and braking are outstanding.
- Performance on dry surfaces is good.
- A tough and durable material.
- An affordable price.
- The ride is smooth and quiet.
Cons
- Ice and heavy snow are not suitable for this product.
Michelin Defender Performance
1. Dry Performance
Tires of this type perform well in dry conditions. At low and medium speeds, they behave like tires of superior quality. For example, when the vehicle is traveling at high speeds on the highway, it behaves superbly when cornering. All-season tires have surprisingly short dry braking distances.
Generally, these tires perform better on dry surfaces than BF Goodrich Advantage Controls.
2. Wet Performance
Michelin Defender offers excellent wet performance and excellent aquaplaning resistance. When cornering at reasonable speeds, they provide excellent grip because of their short braking distances. Despite flooded surfaces or heavy rain, they provide excellent handling.
3. Snow Performance
The performance of these tires is not as good as those of BF Goodrich. For mildly snow-covered roads, they are fine, but not for extremely frozen or thickly snowed surfaces.
4. Comfort and Noise
It is no secret that Michelin products are well-known for their riding comfort and quietness, and the Defender is no exception. Whether on smooth paved highways or gravel secondary roads, the ride quality and road noise are superb.
Pros and Cons of Michelin Defender
Pros
- In wet conditions, the vehicle offers exceptional handling, traction, and braking.
- Exceptional performance on dry surfaces.
- A smooth and quiet ride.
- A tough and durable material.
- This warranty applies.
Cons
- It is not suitable for heavy snow or ice.
- It’s expensive.
Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender: Available Options
You’ll be able to tell which brand offers more options just by looking at the number of families. There is no doubt that Michelin is the more flexible option when comparing tire families with similar categories.
In both the touring and performance segments, BFGoodrich lacks options. Despite covering a wide range of applications, Michelin has multiple models, so there are more options available. It is even possible to choose between different tire models with similar features from different families.
In the same way, there are different types of vehicles. Michelin, for example, has more touring options than BFGoodrich does for CUVs and SUVs. The same is true for track-oriented or performance tires, where you have a lot more flexibility.
Michelin only has one model in this category, so things favor BFGoodrich in all-terrain. However, BFGoodrich is a much better choice in mud-terrain tires because Michelin does not have tires designed for the most extreme off-road conditions.
Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender: Available Sizes
BF As for Goodrich’s Advantage Control tires, they come in sizes ranging from 185/65 R14 to 245/50 R20, while Michelin’s Defender tires come in sizes ranging from 2-5/55 R16 to 245/50 R20. In comparison to Michelin, BF Goodrich offers a greater variety of sizes and styles.
Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender: Price
Despite the relatively small performance differences, there may be some price differences that are noticeable. For example, the g-Force COMP-2 A/S Plus and the Pilot Sport All-Season 4. There is a difference of around $30 between BFGoodrich’s 17-inch model and a 17-inch model of similar size. Michelin’s model has a lower speed rating, which is very important to note.
In the grand touring all-season segment, the CrossClimate 2 and Advantage Control have similar differences. As the Michelin has a higher speed rating, they are technically more comparable. For a 16-inch tire, the BFGoodrich option is around $40 cheaper for the CrossClimate SUV than the Advantage T/A Sport LT.
A/T 2 comes in around $30 more expensive than All-Terrain T/A KO2 in the all-terrain segment. 16-inch models have the same load ratings, but Michelins have a lower maximum speed rating.
Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender: Warranty
The Michelin tire warranty isn’t the longest, but in this comparison, it does seem to be better in some cases. Consider the all-terrain options I mentioned earlier. Michelin’s treadwear warranty is 60,000 miles, while BFGoodrich’s is 50,000.
Some mixed results reported for grand touring all-season models. As with most of their rivals, the CrossClimate 2, Advantage T/A, and T/A Sport all come with a 60,000-mile treadwear warranty. However, the Advantage Control offers a 5,000-mile warranty extension.
When it comes to grand touring SUVs, BFGoodrich is the better choice. As compared to the Advantage T/A Sport LT, the CrossClimate SUV has a treadwear warranty of 50,000 miles.
Which brand to choose: Bf Goodrich Advantage Control Vs Michelin Defender
Choosing a better brand isn’t as easy as it sounds. Numerous models exist, and not all have the same performance difference to make one better than the other.
If you look at the available options and the performance that Michelin tires can offer, it is generally a better brand. In spite of their higher price, these tires will perform better than BFGoodrich’s, especially at the limit. In some conditions, the US manufacturer’s models can perform better, but overall, it’s the French model that wins.
However, this doesn’t make BFGoodrich a bad option by any means. While its models aren’t as extensive as Michelin’s, it can still compete in the premium segment with the rest of them. Best of all, you can sometimes pay less for a tire that offers a bit more in some areas, like warranty. In terms of performance, it’s either on par with Michelin or a bit behind.
Off-road tires are one area where BFGoodrich excels. First of all, Michelin doesn’t have a lot of these, and the ones it has aren’t as good as those from BFGoodrich, especially when it comes to off-roading.
Ultimately, Michelin tires are a great option if you’re looking for excellent road-going tires and price isn’t an issue. Considering that most people won’t drive their cars to their absolute limit, these are the things they might miss.
People who need tires with good performance but aren’t looking to overspend can opt for BFGoodrich, which is the more budget-friendly option. As a result, you will save some money and get a good set of tires.
Conclusion
There’s no doubt that both Goodrich and Michelin models designed using cutting-edge technologies. Taking a look at the performance chart, they are neck and neck in every category.
According to their performance chart, similar behavior, and treadwear warranties, there is no clear winner. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference. In addition, there is no significant price difference; however, if you are able to pay an additional 14%, you could get a product made by one of the world’s top tire manufacturers with some of their top-notch and more expensive features.
Read more of our articles here.
FAQs
Do the Michelin Defender or the BF Goodrich Advantage Control perform better in wet weather?
Due to its silica-based rubber compound and unique tread pattern, the Michelin Defender provides exceptional wet weather traction and hydroplaning resistance.
Do either of these tires perform well in winter conditions?
Its better snow and ice performance makes the Michelin Defender a better winter tire than the BF Goodrich Advantage Control. Winter tires, however, should used in severe weather conditions.
What is the tread life warranty on these tires?
Both the BF Goodrich Advantage Control and Michelin Defender have treadwear warranties. Depending on the model and tire size, the warranty length may vary, so it is important to check with the manufacturer or retailer.
What tire offers the best ride comfort and quietness?
Michelin Defender tires boast superior noise-reduction technology, which makes them slightly quieter and smoother than the Michelin Defender tires.
Are these tires designed for passenger cars or SUVs and trucks?
Both BF Goodrich Advantage Control and Michelin Defender offer options for SUVs, trucks, and passenger cars. A wide range of vehicle sizes are available.